Rochester Contractors: Maintain Proper Lien Law Trust Records

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

For Rochester construction businesses, careful project ledgers help distinguish money available for trust expenses from money available for other uses. New York Lien Law Article 3-A governs the accounting and use of construction trust assets.

Identify the trust and its assets

Lien Law § 70 defines separate owner, contractor and subcontractor trusts. Assets can include both funds received and rights to payment. A trust can arise before any beneficiary’s claim presently exists. Identify the particular contract, improvement, trustee and assets instead of assuming every unpaid invoice proves diversion.

Separate project records; bank accounts may be shared

Section 75 expressly permits funds of different trusts in one bank account if the records clearly allocate deposits and withdrawals to each trust. It does not impose a universal requirement for a specially titled trust account or a separate bank account for every job. A separate account may be a useful control, but it does not replace the statutory books and records.

The records must cover more than a bank balance. Maintain the required information for:

• Trust assets receivable: the person owing payment, identifying transaction, amount and due date.
• Trust accounts payable: beneficiaries, obligations, amounts and dates due.
• Funds received: source, date, amount, form of receipt and deposit information.
• Payments made: recipient, date, amount, method, trust purpose and relevant contract or work details.
• Applicable lending transactions: advances, transfers, assignments and the information required for a notice-of-lending arrangement.

Keep supporting contracts, invoices, payroll records, payment applications, bank records, checks and allocation schedules. Reconcile each project ledger regularly.

Use assets for that trust’s purposes

Section 71 defines permitted expenditures and beneficiaries; qualifying labor, materials and certain project taxes, insurance and bond costs may be included. Using one project’s trust assets for another job or taking profit before the trust obligations are satisfied can create diversion liability under § 72.

For example, if Project X receives $100,000 and pays $75,000 in proper trust expenses, the $25,000 bank balance is not automatically profit. Determine outstanding and potential trust obligations and whether the trust has terminated before releasing remaining assets. If a Project X beneficiary remains unpaid, using that balance to purchase Project Z materials may constitute diversion.

Respond to beneficiary requests

Under § 76, an eligible beneficiary may choose inspection and copying of trust records or a verified statement. The statute generally allows a request after a claim has been payable for 30 days, no more often than monthly, and provides a ten-day response period. Proper identification and service are required. A summary saying the owner has not paid does not replace the required records.

Understand the consequences and deadlines

Missing required records creates presumptive evidence of diversion under § 75; it is not an automatic final judgment. Civil remedies can include accounting, recovery of diverted assets and damages. Individuals who participate in a diversion can face personal liability, but corporate status alone does not establish it. Criminal liability under § 79-a has its own requirements and exceptions. Punitive damages and attorney-fee awards are not automatic.

Bankruptcy treatment also requires separate analysis. In Bullock v. BankChampaign, N.A., 569 U.S. 267 (2013), the Supreme Court required a culpable mental state for fiduciary defalcation under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(4), including knowledge or gross recklessness. It is inaccurate to say every Article 3-A judgment necessarily survives an individual’s bankruptcy.

Section 77 generally limits a trust-enforcement action to one year after completion of the improvement, with a later final-payment-due trigger available to subcontractors and materialmen as stated in the statute. It also provides representative-action requirements and an exception for a trustee’s final-accounting action. Obtain a claim-specific deadline analysis; a records request does not automatically extend the time to sue.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists with construction trust accounting disputes and diversion claims and construction payment litigation. Vincent T. Pallaci is the firm’s managing member. Call 631-752-7100, email vtp@kushnicklaw.com or consult the current Long Island and New York City office information.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.